Taste. Review. Remember.

Whisky Reviews /My Whisky Diary

Empowering the whisky world with shared whisky journeys.

Discover tasting notes, ratings and your personal Whisky Diary in one polished community workspace.

Total Reviews0
Whiskies Reviewed0
Reviewers0

Community Rating Overview

Tap to view whiskies in this rating range

Sign in to publish your tasting notes from the full composer.Write a Review

All reviews

Community Reviews

From the Maltiply community

Community Reviews

Lark Distillery Darkest Before Dawn 8 Year Old, Oloroso Sherry Cask, Cask #LD559, 2009, Heartwood, 64%
#2United Kingdom
Lark Distillery Darkest Before Dawn 8 Year Old, Oloroso Sherry Cask, Cask #LD559, 2009, Heartwood, 64%
84/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The lightly peated label catches my eye, but the notes focus on brown sugar, figs, and a savoury finish of beef broth and salt. That sweet-to-savoury turn is the part that stands out.

Nose: Brown sugar, Yoghurt, Cream, Boozy stone fruits, Dried figs, Peanut brittlePalate: Toffee apples, Dark caramel, Brown sugar, Bitter chocolate, Tobacco, Strawberries and cream, Fresh and dried figFinish: Chewy and massive, Beef broth, Salt, Gravy granules
Brown sugarYoghurtCreamBoozy stone fruits
Littlemill Connoisseurs Choice 19 Year Old, Refill Bourbon Cask, 1991, Gordon & MacPhail, 43%
#3Norway
Littlemill Connoisseurs Choice 19 Year Old, Refill Bourbon Cask, 1991, Gordon & MacPhail, 43%
84/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The light, fragrant nose and delicate sweetness suggest a gentle style, with a fresh, sweet finish. I like how clearly the notes convey that character, though they point to restraint rather than a bold profile.

Nose: Light and fragrant, Hint of citrusPalate: Touch of perfume, Delicate sweetnessFinish: Sweet and fresh
Light and fragrantHint of citrusTouch of perfumeDelicate sweetness
Springbank 18 Year Old, Sherry & Bourbon Cask, 2010 Release, 2010, 46%
#4United Kingdom
Springbank 18 Year Old, Sherry & Bourbon Cask, 2010 Release, 2010, 46%
88/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The citrus and aniseed against chilli and pine make this more interesting than a straightforward rich-fruit malt. Sweet liquorice and the long, salty chocolate-caramel finish add a welcome counterpoint. It sounds bold and layered, though the sweet side may be quite prominent.

Nose: Toasted bananas, honey and Bakewell tarts, Coastal hints, vanilla, ripe fruits and marzipan, Hints of sherbet, almonds and strawberriesPalate: Chilli, pine, citrus and aniseed, Rich fruits, sweet liquorice and aniseedFinish: Long, salty chocolate caramels, Hints of smoky fruit and coconut, Pleasant smoky tingle
Toasted bananas, honey and Bakewell tartsCoastal hints, vanilla, ripe fruits and marzipanHints of sherbet, almonds and strawberriesChilli, pine, citrus and aniseed
Ichiro's Malt Karuizawa 1983 Ichiro's Choice Sherry Influence 24 Year Old, Sherry Cask, Cask #8601, 1983, Ichiro Akuto, 59%
#5Hong Kong
Ichiro's Malt Karuizawa 1983 Ichiro's Choice Sherry Influence 24 Year Old, Sherry Cask, Cask #8601, 1983, Ichiro Akuto, 59%
88/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The dark chocolate and dried figs make for a rich start, while ginger spice gives the palate a useful contrast. The long, warming finish sounds appealing, though this is a bold, weighty style rather than a restrained one.

Nose: Dark chocolate, Roasted coffee beans, Dried figs, Sandalwood and Japanese incensePalate: Viscous, mouth-coating texture, Black treacle, Ginger spice, Antique leatherFinish: Long and warming, Umami, Dark fruits, Hint of wood smoke
Dark chocolateRoasted coffee beansDried figsSandalwood and Japanese incense
Bimber Shoulders of Giants - Nicolaus - The Inventor, Oloroso Sherry Cask, Cask #446, 2025, 57.9%
#6United Kingdom
Bimber Shoulders of Giants - Nicolaus - The Inventor, Oloroso Sherry Cask, Cask #446, 2025, 57.9%
88/100Excellent!Strong Buy

Dark dried fruits and ripe fruit give this a clear fruit-led appeal, with sherry richness and dark caramel adding depth. A warm, weighty style that suits my preferences.

Nose: Dark dried fruits, Fine wood, A hint of spice, Delicate sweetness, Subtle nuttinessPalate: Rich sherry notes, Dark caramel, Ripe fruits, A hint of chocolateFinish: N.A
Dark dried fruitsFine woodA hint of spiceDelicate sweetness
Macallan Chinese New Year Limited Edition 1 12 Year Old, Sherry & Bourbon Cask, 40%
#7Malaysia
Macallan Chinese New Year Limited Edition 1 12 Year Old, Sherry & Bourbon Cask, 40%
83/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The notes lean sweet, with butterscotch, candied orange and raisins alongside oak and mild spice. Smoke isn’t established by the sensory description, so I’d keep the smoke call open rather than label it smoky or smoke-free.

Nose: Creamy butterscotch, Toffee apple, Candied orange, Vanilla custard, Fresh oak, Tropical fruits, raisins, and soft spicePalate: Honey, Wood spices, Citrus, Raisins, Caramel, Ginger, Milk chocolate, Creamy toffee, Vanilla and almondFinish: Medium, warm, sweet, and drying, Lingering oak, almonds, and mild spice
Creamy butterscotchToffee appleCandied orangeVanilla custard
Linkwood Whiskyheroes: Back to the Roots 12 Year Old, Bourbon Cask, Cask #2312111 & 2312115/2015, Brave New Spirits, 56.7%
#8Malaysia
Linkwood Whiskyheroes: Back to the Roots 12 Year Old, Bourbon Cask, Cask #2312111 & 2312115/2015, Brave New Spirits, 56.7%
84/100Excellent!Strong Buy

Vanilla and spice give this a clear centre, while roasted grain and ripe apricot and peach add contrast to the sweetness on the nose. On the palate, vanilla and oak spice sit alongside sweet muesli bars, fruits and oatmeal. That combination appeals to my taste, particularly where the grain notes give the sweeter flavours something to play against. The palate is described as powerful and aromatic, though, so it may be more assertive than I usually prefer. The spicy aftertaste and light sweetness keep that contrast going through the finish. There is plenty here to hold my interest, even if I would lean toward a little more restraint on the palate.

Nose: spice and sweetness, vanilla, roasted grain, ripe apricot and peachPalate: powerful and aromatic, vanilla and oak spice, sweet muesli bars with fruits and oatmealFinish: spicy aftertaste, light sweetness
spice and sweetnessvanillaroasted grainripe apricot and peach
Johnnie Walker Blenders' Batch Sweet Peat, Bourbon & Sherry Cask, 2018, 40.8%
#9New Zealand
Johnnie Walker Blenders' Batch Sweet Peat, Bourbon & Sherry Cask, 2018, 40.8%
79/100Very Good!Worth Trying

Polished wood on the nose gives the oak side something to work with, but it seems less central once the vegetal and floral palate takes over. Coffee and chocolate recur, while the short, vegetal finish leaves that wood note feeling more like an opening detail than the main thread.

Nose: Polished wood, nutmeg, pear, apple, hazelnuts, boiled chestnuts, coffee candy, milk chocolate, red fruit cereal bar, and an initial hint of solvent.Palate: A sweet opening with coffee candy and chocolate, an elusive hint of smoke, vegetal and floral notes including violet, and fruit notes.Finish: Short and vegetal, with coffee, apple, cereal, and slight smoke or smoked spice.
Polished wood, nutmeg, pear, apple, hazelnuts, boiled chestnuts, coffee candy, milk chocolate, red fruit cereal bar, and an initial hint of solvent.A sweet opening with coffee candy and chocolate, an elusive hint of smoke, vegetal and floral notes including violet, and fruit notes.Short and vegetal, with coffee, apple, cereal, and slight smoke or smoked spice.
Singleton Glen Ord 12 Year Old, American & European Oak Cask, Muscat Finish, 40%
#10Australia
Singleton Glen Ord 12 Year Old, American & European Oak Cask, Muscat Finish, 40%
86/100Excellent!Strong Buy

The vanilla sweetness has welcome company in light sherry and berry-fruit aromas, so it reads as more than a one-note sweet dram. Creamy, rich, rounded fruit on the palate keeps that balance going, while the warming, smooth finish sounds like a measured close rather than a sharp contrast. A quietly appealing combination; the sweetness is present, but the fruit and sherry give it shape.

Nose: Vanilla sweetness, Light sherry, Berry-fruit aromasPalate: Creamy, Rich, Rounded, Fruity characterFinish: Warming, Smooth
Vanilla sweetnessLight sherryBerry-fruit aromasCreamy
Showing 1 to 10 of 100 reviews
...
Real PeopleVerified community reviews
Honest OpinionsNo paid or sponsored reviews
Tasting InsightsTaste, notes and experience
Global CommunityFrom the Maltiply community
Share your experienceWrite a review and help others discover great whiskies.Write a Review