Community Review

Caol Ila Connoisseurs Choice 12 Year Old, Refill Bourbon Butt Cask, Cask #112010, Batch No. 21/082, 2008, Gordon & MacPhail, 57%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

89 / 100

This is the kind of Islay character I’m drawn to. Sweet peat smoke sits alongside vanilla fudge, citrus oil and roasted nuts, so there’s more going on than smoke alone. I especially like the turn toward brine and sweet malt on the long, warming finish, with bonfire embers keeping a coastal edge in view. Cured meats, red apples, cinnamon and black pepper give the nose a savory, lively feel.

Reviewed by maple.fox

Nose
Cured meats, Red apples, Cinnamon, Cracked black pepper
Palate
Sweet peat smoke, Vanilla fudge, Citrus oil, Roasted nuts
Finish
Long and warming, Bonfire embers, Brine, Sweet malt

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.