Islay South Coast A Dream of Scotland 14 Year Old, First Fill Cream Sherry Butt Cask, Batch No. Bad Santa III, Brühler Whiskyhaus, 53.7%

The creamy sweetness gives the maritime smoke a softer edge, though the smoke grows more pronounced and the long, dry finish sounds less easygoing. A compelling balance, if not a gentle style.

Reviewed by redkitewren

Nose

Creamy caramel, ripe greengages, mango and pear, with maritime smoke and kelp.

Palate

Creamy sweetness and smoke, with caramel, cherry syrup, ripe blackberries, dark chocolate and spices.

Finish

Long and dry, with maritime smoke, ash, tar, eucalyptus and minerals.