Community Review

Rosebank The Roses Edition Five - Fascination 21 Year Old, Madeira & American Oak Cask, Edition No. 5, Elixir Distillers, 49.5%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

88 / 100

The fruit has a clear path here: lemon, tangerine and white peaches on the nose give way to broader orchard fruits on the palate, then fragrant lemons return in the finish. That makes the fruit easy to follow without reducing the whisky to a simple citrus theme. Floral and herbal notes sit alongside the palate’s deep sweetness, while almonds and mild spices add contrast. The touch of leather and tobacco is a useful qualification: anyone looking mainly for bright fruit may find the palate less straightforward. The long, delicate finish, with evolving fruits, spices and ginger, should appeal to someone who likes fruit to remain present as other notes develop. For my taste, that balance is the main attraction.

Reviewed by busstop compass

Nose
lemon, tangerine, white peaches, soft floral notes
Palate
orchard fruits, herbal and floral notes, almonds, mild spices, a touch of leather and tobacco
Finish
evolving fruits and spices, ginger, fragrant lemons

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.