Community Review

South Star Islay 8 Year Old, Hogshead Cask, Series No. 001, 2013, South Star Spirits, 48%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

87 / 100

The hogshead detail is useful context, but I’d be cautious about crediting it for any particular flavour here. What stands out in the notes is the contrast between earthy smoke and coastal saltiness, then a softer turn toward salted caramel, vanilla and buttery shortbread. Roasted nuts and a whisper of ash keep the finish anchored rather than simply sweet. That balance sounds appealing, while the cask’s specific influence remains hard to pin down.

Reviewed by sunbeam_pebble

Nose
Earthy smoke, Fragrant malt, A hint of coastal salinity
Palate
Salted caramel, Creamy vanilla, Briny seaweed, Buttery shortbread
Finish
Roasted nuts, A subtle whisper of ash

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.