Community Review

Thompson Bros Sutherland 9 Year Old, Refill American Oak Barrel Cask, 2010, Thompson Bros, 51.3%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

88 / 100

The enjoyable tension here is between waxy, salty character and the brighter fruit: apple and citrus keep the brine from taking over. Capers and olives make the nose a little unusual, but the palate’s soft woody spice sounds like a steady counterpoint rather than another competing voice. I’m drawn to that clear contrast; it gives the fruit something interesting to play against. A characterful Highland single malt, with enough familiar apple and citrus to keep its saltier side approachable. Nothing about this sounds like it needs a long explanation—though “briny wax” is not exactly a pub-menu phrase.

Reviewed by SunbeamRadio

Nose
Waxy, Apples and pears, Unripe mango, Slightly salty, with capers and olives
Palate
Waxy and salty, Soft woody spices, Citrus peel, green apple and kumquat, Chrysalis
Finish
Brine around a waxy texture, Dried currants, Star anise and orange peel

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.