Community Review

Caol Ila Raw Cask 9 Year Old, Refill Hogshead Cask, Cask #10637, Lot No. 18847, 1992, Blackadder, 58.6%

A Maltiply member's tasting notes and whisky impression.

78 / 100

The fruit comes through in a darker, sharper way here: cherry cough syrup on the nose, then lemon pepper and a lightly sweet lemonade note against thick, spicy peat. That contrast gives it more character than straightforward sweetness, while the finish leans hard into smoke, tangy zest and raw sugar. The chemical and bitter edges in the notes make this sound challenging rather than easygoing, but the fruit-and-smoke combination is compelling.

Reviewed by wildmintkit

Nose
Sweet and salty, with burnt treacle, lemon pepper and cherry cough syrup., Creamy, earthy peat and fireplace soot.
Palate
Acidic ash and thick, spicy peat., Lemonade with light sugar.
Finish
Raw sugar, tangy zest and billowing smoke., Molasses and subtle mint oil.

Reviews of other bottles from the Maltiply community.